The Solutions Party

Time to Make Lobbying Fairer and More Transparent 

Home Contact About Español

“Let’s reform lobbying to ensure politicians serve the public—not special interests”

Our Proposal:

  •  All elected officials to conduct lobbying meetings only in public sessions
  •  Lobbying sessions to be applied for and posted on official web sites
  •  Equal time to be given to alternate views at all lobbying sessions

The Goal:

  •  Eliminate the lack of transparency in our politics
  •  No more hidden arrangements between our elected officials and special interests
  •  Help ensure our elected officials consider equally all points of view 

Explanation:

When we, the voters, entrust our elected officials with the people’s power, we expect them to use it to improve our lives and make our society more prosperous. We want them to build a future rich in opportunity—one in which our children can enjoy a higher quality of life than previous generations

But things don’t seem to be improving. More of us are struggling to make ends meet and are frustrated by the growing threats to our quality of life: unaffordable housing, soaring education costs, an increasingly precarious job market, the sense that we’re working harder but getting less in return, and rising grocery and medical costs. These and other pressures are disillusioning us with politics and making us increasingly anxious about the future.

While more of us struggle, we see power and wealth becoming increasingly concentrated at the top. Our government seems to work more and more for the powerful than for the public—but this is no mere illusion. Over the past 50 years, the share of U.S. wealth held by the top 1% has risen, while the middle class has shrunk. The evidence is not only in the statistics; it is visible in everyday life. South Carolina Representative Tim Burchett summed it up best in an NPR interview when he said Washington is a place focused on keeping the powerful in power.

There is no single reason our democracy and government are not functioning as they should. The problems facing our country and communities are complex, and addressing them will require bold, multifaceted solutions. But we can begin to reform politics by recognizing that elected officials too often put their own political careers first—especially their efforts to stay in power and satisfy the special interests that help them do so. 

The Role of Lobbying:

Powerful organizations lobby elected officials and often form alliances with them, seeking favorable laws and regulations in exchange for political support. That support may take the form of campaign contributions, spending through political action committees, or the promotion of culture-war issues that benefit favored politicians. These mutually beneficial alliances shape how—and for whom—government works, undermining public policy and democracy. Too often, laws and policies reflect the interests of powerful organizations with close ties to politicians rather than the interests of the public.

These relationships can even blur the line between legitimate lobbying and corruption. For example, evidence that a campaign contribution was made in exchange for favorable official action could raise bribery concerns, even if a quid-pro-quo agreement between the parties was never discussed openly. (A contribution followed by a favorable decision does not of course, by itself, prove a corrupt exchange). The problem is compounded by gaps in disclosure, which can make it difficult to determine how much special-interest spending is influencing government.

Let’s be clear: lobbying is a constitutional right. But lobbying too often lacks transparency, and its benefits can be skewed toward those with connections or the resources to play “pay to play.” In Federalist No. 10, James Madison argued that a large republic containing many competing interests could make it harder for any one faction to dominate government. That idea offers a useful starting point for thinking about reforms that broaden representation and curb the influence of the most powerful interests.

Proposal for Reform:

Let’s bring complete transparency and equity to the lobbying process. We propose that reforms to lobbying should implement at a minimum two major changes: 1) make lobbying much more visible to the public, and 2) put into place a mechanism that ensures our elected officials are hearing all sides of any given issue. Specifically, we propose:

  1. Elected officials shall not meet privately with lobbyists. All lobbying must be conducted through publicly scheduled lobbying sessions.
  2. Access for lobbying must be requested exclusively through a lobbying petition submitted and posted publicly on the elected official’s website.
  3. Upon acceptance of a lobbying petition, the elected official shall schedule a public lobbying session, posting at least the date, time, and agenda on their official website
  4. Lobbying entities must upload a copy of their planned presentation materials to the elected official’s website or other designated public platform, not later than fourteen days before the scheduled lobbying session.
  5. The public lobbying session shall permit participation by individuals and organizations not affiliated with the lobbying entity, allowing them to submit alternative viewpoints, comments, or presentations.
  6. Each public lobbying session shall be limited to 120 minutes, structured to include:
  1. The original presentation by the lobbying entity;
  2. Presentation(s) of opposing or alternative viewpoints;
  3. An open and moderated debate;
  4. A question and answer period involving the elected official and participants.

EXCEPTIONS.—Notwithstanding the proposed requirements above, elected officials may conduct private lobbying meetings under the following circumstances:

  1. Constituent casework, meaning assistance provided by an elected official directly addressing issues relating to an individual constituent’s personal or administrative matters.
  2. Confidential personal matters, meaning private information concerning personal or family matters protected by law or custom against public disclosure
  3. Attorney-client privileged communications.
  4. Meetings justified by credible safety concerns, meaning  a reasonable and documented threat to the physical safety of an elected official or others, requiring a non-public meeting, documented contemporaneously.
  5. Elected officials shall document the basis for any private meeting under an exception and make such documentation available upon reasonable public request consistent with law and security constraints.
  6. Matters involving trade or national security where the elected official reasonably fears that public disclosure could compromise such matters, provided that:
  1. A sanitized summary of the meeting shall be posted promptly on the official’s website, removing classified or sensitive details but describing the general nature and outcome;
  2. Opportunities for the public to provide alternate points of view regarding the general matter must be made available through the elected official’s official website.

If adopted, the above proposed reforms should 1) make it much harder for elected officials and special interests to form opaque, self-serving alliances, putting their interests ahead of voters and the public in the process, 2) significantly increase lobbying transparency, and 3) ensure that our elected officials are exposed to the multiple points of view around any given issue. 

Let’s do this!

Solutions Party Twitter Feed